Albinism in popular culture

The depiction of albinism in popular culture, especially the portrayal of people with albinism in film and fiction, has been asserted by albinism organizations and others to be largely negative and has raised concerns that it reinforces, or even engenders, societal prejudice and discrimination against such people.[1] This trend is sometimes referred to as the "evil albino" plot device[1] or albino bias.[2][3][4]

The "evil albino" stereotype is a villain in fiction who is depicted as being albinistic (or displaying physical traits usually associated with albinism, even if the term is not used), with the specific and obvious purpose of distinguishing the villain in question from the heroes by means of appearance.[1][5] Traits of albinism commonly associated with the evil albino stereotype include pale skin, platinum blonde hair, and blue or pink-to-red eyes. Notably absent from most depictions is impaired vision, which is experienced by most real people with albinism.[1][6][7]

The stereotype has become sufficiently well-recognized to attract satire and to be considered a cliché. In response to the "albino gunmen" characters in The Da Vinci Code and The Matrix Reloaded, albinistic actor Dennis Hurley wrote, produced and starred in a short film parody, The Albino Code, playing up the stereotypes, illustrating a typical example of real-world prejudice, and pointing out that the vision problems associated with albinism would make a successful career as a hitman highly improbable. In The Big Over Easy, author Jasper Fforde includes an "albino community" protest against albino bias among his fictional news clippings, most of which satirize stock characters and hackneyed plot devices. Chicago Tribune movie reviewer Mark Caro says of this character type that it is someone "who looks albino and thus, in movie shorthand, must be vicious."[8] The National Organization for Albinism and Hypopigmentation (NOAH) has stated that there were a total of sixty-eight films from 1960 to 2006 featuring an "evil albino".[9]

Conversely, a number of real people with albinism have risen to fame (see "Famous people with albinism" section, below), especially in popular music (though, as in the case of the Winter brothers, may themselves be the subject of "evil albino" parody). Albino animals capture public imagination and wonder as zoo attractions, and even in the wild can attract popular, positive attention (see "Notable albino animals" section, below).

Contents

History of the "evil albino" stereotype

The "evil albino" stereotype may also have its roots in Neolithic Eastern Europe, where some cultures depicted Death as a pallid woman with light hair.[10] Fear of vampires and other legendary undead with a deathly pallor, especially in European folklore, could also have contributed to albino bias. The phenomenon may also have been influenced by attitudes towards people with albinism in Africa or Jamaica, where those with that condition are sometimes regarded as cursed or magical (see folklore section, below). Dermatologist Dr. Vail Reese theorizes that albino bias may be part of a broader Hollywood pattern of equating or at least linking skin disorders and appearance problems with villainy.[11]

Another explanation may be sought in respective ideals of ugliness — most "evil albinos" appear in works of fiction from the West. In fiction from Japan, where ideals call for as pale skin as possible, characters with albinism or associated traits are more frequently sympathetic[12] than in American and British fiction.[13] This is not to say that Japanese popular culture has not depicted "evil albinos". However, such characters in Japanese fiction are often bishōnen or bishōjo whose beautiful appearance gives contrast to their evil character. Use of albinistic features to indicate villains in Hollywood's film appears to have begun in the 1960s, and may be related to the popularity of tanning (and thus a decrease in pale skin being seen as attractive) in this period.[5]

One of the oldest perceived literary examples of albino bias was H.G. Wells's depiction of the main character in his 1897 science-fiction novel The Invisible Man, who was able to become invisible using his scientific discoveries only because he already lacked natural pigmentation; aberrant even before his experimentation, he subsequently became completely deranged, an "albino villain".

Albino bias is also alleged in modern times. For example, the 2003 Warner Bros movie The Matrix Reloaded featured two sociopathic characters with pale skin and white hair frequently interpreted to be albinos despite studio declarations that they are not.[7] Positive depictions of albinos in mass culture are rarer, though one example is the 1995 film Powder which depicts an exceptionally gifted albinistic youth and the cruelty he endures because of his differences from "normal" people. In recent years, the National Organization for Albinism and Hypopigmentation (NOAH) has spoken out[1] against albino bias in the United States. Albinistic actor Michael C. Bowman, of Me, Myself and Irene, has said, "Kids all over this country are being affected in a very negative and harmful way because of the sloppiness and laziness of a writer in Hollywood."[7]

Albinism and fiction

Note: These lists do not include characters whose appearance is reminiscent of albininism, but for reasons other than actual albinism. These include but are not limited to aliens, the undead, magical beings, unusually-colored anime/manga characters, etc. An exception is characters commonly perceived to be albinistic.

A number of movies, books and other works have been criticized[1][5][6] for albino bias, as they associate the uncommon features of albinistic people (pale skin, white hair, and unpigmented eyes) with danger, terror, or criminality. Less frequently they are depicted as the harmless butt of jokes and ridicule, as maladjusted and undersocializled, or as "freaks".[5][14] They may also actually be portrayed positively, even heroically – a more recent counter-trend.

Negatively portrayed characters

Brothers Edgar and Johnny Winter, rock musicians with albinism subject to parody as "evil albinos" in a comic book.

The most common depiction of people with albinism in fiction is that of the inimical, violent villain, especially the hitman, assassin, sociopath or crime boss.[5][6][7][14]

Animals and other non-humanoid characters

Subjects of ridicule and "freaks"

Recently, there has been an increase in the number albinistic characters who are mocked (sometimes by the actual works in which they appear, an instance of albino bias itself, and sometimes by other characters in a way that highlights albino bias).

Neutrally or ambiguously portrayed characters

Neutral and least morally uncertain depictions of persons with albinism are also somewhat common in literature and film, as anti-heroes, morally confused characters, or simply incidentally.

Animals and other non-humanoid characters

Positively portrayed characters

Persons with albinism are sometimes depicted heroically or otherwise positively, or at least accurately with regard to their condition and its medical and social results:

Animals and other non-humanoid characters

Other references to albinism

Folklore, urban legends and myths

In some cultures, people with albinism are believed in folklore to have magical powers or to be able to tell the future, a common theme in fiction as well.

Africa

In Zimbabwe, modern folklore posits that sexual intercourse with an albinistic person will cure one of HIV, leading to the rape (and subsequent HIV infection) of women with albinism in that region.[47]

In Tanzania in 2008, President Kikwete publicly condemned witch doctors for opportunistic persecution of albinism, including a spate of murders of albinistic people (over 50 since March 2007, as of October 2008,[48] and initially limited to Tanzania) for their body parts which are thought to bring good luck – hair, arms, legs and blood are used to make potions which the witchdoctors claim will bring prosperity. Consequently, graves of the albinistic have to be sealed with cement to discourage grave robbers.[49][50][51][52] By June 2008 killings had been reported in neighboring Kenya and possibly also the Democratic Republic of Congo,[50][53] spreading to Burundi by October 2008.[54] (See Persecution of people with albinism for more information.)

Caribbean

In Jamaica, people with albinism were historically degraded, and regarded as "cursed". In recent times, the albinistic musicians King Yellowman and Al Beeno have helped to curb this stereotype.

North America

The 2004 book Weird N.J.[55] (a tie-in to the History Channel TV series Weird U.S.) chronicled, failed to prove, yet further popularized one of the lesser-known local urban legends of the US, "albino colonies". The book uses alleged firsthand accounts mailed to the authors to paint a picture of various locations in the U.S. (most notably Clifton, New Jersey) where aggregations of albinistic families are said to live in seclusion. The accounts tell tales of honking horns to try to bring the residents out of their houses, of gawkers being shot at by residents, and even of gangs of local albinistic vigilantes.

In some versions of the sewer alligator urban legends, the alligators supposedly became albinistic due to mutation (which is implausible due to the short time scale) and/or lack of exposure to sunlight (which erroneously conflates pallor due to lack of exposure to sunlight with albinism).[56]

South America

Among the Kuna of Panama and Colombia, the albinistic have a special place in the indigenous mythology.[57]

Notable people with albinism

People commonly mistaken to have albinism

Roy Orbison was falsely said to be albinistic, by his widow, for unknown reasons.[68] German singer Heino has Graves disease, which can be mistaken for albinism. Actor Anthony Rapp fronts a rock band called Albinokid, but is not albinistic, being a normally pigmented Caucasian. London mayor Boris Johnson, known for his pale hair, has also been mistakenly called albino. In general, platinum blonde ("towheaded") people with very pale skin can be mistaken for albinistic (and conversely, some forms of albinism can result in phenotypes so normal-looking that only genetic testing can reveal the albinistic genes).

Notable albino animals

An albino humpback whale called Migaloo (Australian Aboriginal for "White Lad") travels the east coast of Australia, and has become famous in the local media.[69][70] Bristol Zoo was the home to a very rare albino African penguin named Snowdrop, who was hatched at the zoo in October 2002 and died in August 2004.[71][72] For many years, a unique albino gorilla named Floquet de Neu in Catalan and Copito de Nieve in Spanish (both meaning "Snowflake"), was the most famous resident of the Parc Zoològic de Barcelona.[73] In 2009 a pink albino bottlenose dolphin, nicknamed Pinky, was sighted several times in an inland lake in the United States,[74] and footage of it has become popular on Internet video sites. There is also an albino crocodile in Jungle Island theme park in Miami, Fl.

Perhaps the most significant albino animal in history was Mocha Dick, a sperm whale of the early 19th century that lived mostly near the island of Mocha, off Chile's southern Pacific coast, several decades before Herman Melville fictionalized him in the 1851 novel Moby-Dick. The real whale was renowned for being docile until attacked whereupon he became ferocious and capable of disabling smaller vessels. This made him widely feared among whaler crews, though also a target for adventurous captains, who engaged him in possibly as many as hundred or more sea battles before he was eventually killed.

References


  1. ^ a b c d e f "'Evil Albino' missing from 2004 movies. Will The Da Vinci Code revive the cliché?", The National Organization for Albinism and Hypopigmentation, January 6, 2005; accessed December 15, 2006
  2. ^ "Matrix makers blast charge of albino-bias — Warner Bros. says blockbuster sequel in no way demeans pigment-challenged", by Joe Kovacs, WorldNetDaily, May 15, 2003; accessed December 15, 2006.
  3. ^ "New 'Matrix' Film Accused of Albino-Bias", by Cinnamon Stillwell, ChronWatch, May 16, 2003; accessed December 15, 2006
  4. ^ "Cold Mountain", at The Global Oneness Commitment archive; accessed December 25, 2006.
  5. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r "Beyond the pale: Hollywood's unwritten rules for characters with albinism", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese; accessed December 15, 2006
  6. ^ a b c d "Furor Over The Matrix: Reloaded", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese; accessed December 15, 2006
  7. ^ a b c d e f g h i "Furor Over The Matrix: Reloaded — Continued", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese; accessed December 15, 2006
  8. ^ "Movie review: Cold Mountain"; Caro, Mark; Chicago Tribune (online edition), date unspecified; accessed 13 March 2007
  9. ^ "Early viewers pan Da Vinci Code: Film's release also provokes widespread protests"; no by-line; CNN.com "Entertainment" section / Associated Press Newswire, 17 May 2006; accessed 13 March 2007
  10. ^ The Language of the Goddess, Marija Gimbutas, 1989, page 198
  11. ^ "Most movies that feature skin disease use it to represent evil", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese; accessed December 15, 2006
  12. ^ a b "Japanese Anime and Manga", Albinism in Popular Culture, by Luna Eterna, 1997–2006; accessed January 8, 2007
  13. ^ "American and British Comics", Albinism in Popular Culture, by Luna Eterna, 1997–2006; accessed January 8, 2007
  14. ^ a b c "Book two of Hollywood's rules of albinism", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese.
  15. ^ "The Da Vinci Code Albinos[sic] Murderer Depiction Was Slammed"; Gheorghe, Adina; Softpedia Reviews, 20 March 2006; accessed 13 March 2007
  16. ^ Dan Brown's FAQ Retrieved on April 21, 2007.
  17. ^ "The Matrix Reloaded", at IMDb
  18. ^ "C.A. Revives Rock Stars’ Suit Over Use of Their Personae", Metropolitan News-Enterprise, June 20, 2002; accessed December 15, 2006.
  19. ^ AP Newswire (Washington, DC: Associated Press). March 3, 2006. http://www.firstamendmentcenter.org/news.aspx?id=11551. Retrieved December 17, 2009. 
  20. ^ Vamp, at IMDb
  21. ^ a b "Contact", at IMDb
  22. ^ "Lethal Weapon", at IMDb.
  23. ^ "Images of Charlie Hunnam", IMDb
  24. ^ "Cold Mountain", at IMDb.
  25. ^ "Cold Mountain Movie Review: Moving 'Mountain'"; Burr, Ty; Boston Globe (online edition), 25 December 2003; accessed 13 March 2007
  26. ^ "The Princess Bride", at IMDb.
  27. ^ "End of days", at IMDb
  28. ^ "Foul Play (1978)", at IMDb
  29. ^ "Stick", at IMDb.
  30. ^ "Freefall", at IMDb.
  31. ^ "Hitman: Blood Money (VG)", at IMDb.
  32. ^ "House of 1000 Corpses", at IMDb
  33. ^ "The Devil's Rejects", at IMDb
  34. ^ Screen-capture demonstrating that the Klingon Albino is both, from Memory Alpha, 1 December 2006; accessed 31 March 2007
  35. ^ "The Man Who Would Be Bat". Thomas Pugsley and Greg Klein (writers). The Batman. 2004-10-30. No. 4, season 1.
  36. ^ Saldanha, Carols (dir.), et al.. Ice Age: Dawn of the Dinosaurs (DVD, "Filmmaker Commentary" audio track). Century City, CA: 20th Century Fox. Event occurs at 1:16:15. 
  37. ^ http://www.multiverse.org/fora/showthread.php?t=538
  38. ^ Crowe, Joe (April 25, 2008). "Elric: Stealer of Souls Reviewed". Revolution Science Fiction. Drums, PA: Revolution Web Development. http://www.revolutionsf.com/article.php?id=4045. Retrieved December 16, 2009. 
  39. ^ a b "Realistic Characters with Genetic Conditions", Skinema: Dermatology in the Cinema, Dr. Vail Reese; accessed December 15, 2006
  40. ^ "Full cast and crew for Nobody's Fool (1986)", at IMDb
  41. ^ "Spartacus: Blood and Sand". TVTropes.com. Rice Lake, WI: Gu Straley. 2010. http://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/Ptitlelr67penz. Retrieved March 3, 2010. 
  42. ^ Melville, Herman (1851). "The Whiteness of The Whale". Moby-Dick; or, the Whale. Richard Bentley. ISBN 1587299062. http://www.gutenberg.org/files/2701/2701-h/2701-h.htm. "And of all these things the Albino whale was the symbol." 
  43. ^ Campbell, Michelle (2010). Lentara. pp. 335. 
  44. ^ Salter, Adam (2007). The Platinum Prison. Raleigh, NC: Lulu Ent. back cover blurb. ISBN 978-1-847-5344-1. 
  45. ^ "Review: The Strangely Beautiful Tale of Miss Percy Parker". Publishers Weekly. New York: Reed Business Information. ISSN 0000-0019. Archived from the original on or after August 20, 2009. http://www.amazon.com/dp/0843962968. Retrieved September 21, 2009. 
  46. ^ "Times Educational Supplement: An Awkward Age".
  47. ^ ipsnews.net
  48. ^ Orton Kiishweko (October 20, 2008). "Tanzania: JK Orders Crackdown to Stem Murder of Albinos.". Dar es Salaam: The Citizen. http://allafrica.com/stories/200810200901.html. 
  49. ^ "Tanzania Albinos Targeted Again". BBC News (online edition) (British Broadcasting Corporation). 2008-07-27. http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/africa/7527729.stm. Retrieved 2008-07-27. 
  50. ^ a b Gettleman, Jeffrey (June 8, 2008). "Albinos, Long Shunned, Face Threat in Tanzania". New York Times (New York, NY: New York Times Company). http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/08/world/africa/08albino.html. 
  51. ^ http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/africa/7518049.stm
  52. ^ {{Cite web url= http://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/africa/crackdown-on-witchdoctors-after-albinos-killed-to-harvest-body-parts-804545.html |title=Crackdown on Witchdoctors After Albinos Killed to Harvest Body Parts |first=Claire |last=Soares |date=4 April 2008 |work=The Independent |at="World: Africa" section |location=London |publisher=Independent News and Media Ltd |accessdate=16 December 2009 }}
  53. ^ John Kulekana (October 21, 2008). "Crackdown Vowed After Tanzania Albino Girl Killed, Mutilated". Agence France-Presse. http://www.canada.com/topics/news/world/story.html?id=d9487de6-5eeb-4b6e-b21f-4863db51113c. 
  54. ^ Esdras Ndikumanna (October 14, 2008). "Burundi's albinos flee sorcerers and organ traders". Agence France-Presse. http://www.france24.com/20081014-burundis-albinos-flee-sorcerers-organ-traders. 
  55. ^ Moran, Mark; Sceurman, Mark (2003). Weird N.J.: Your Travel Guide to New Jersey's Local Legends and Best Kept Secrets. Sterling Publications. ISBN 0-760739-79-X. 
  56. ^ http://www.delorenzosdugout.com/urbanlegends.htm
  57. ^ Oculocutaneous albinism: clinical, historical and anthropological aspects
  58. ^ a b c d e f g h i j k l m n o p q r s t u See main article(s) on topic mentioned for sources.
  59. ^ a b c Centers, S. (2005). "Famous People with Albinism". SARA-Foundation.com. Campbell, California: Supporting Albinism Research and Awareness. Archived from the original on 23 April 2008. http://web.archive.org/web/20080423145250/http://www.sara-foundation.com/famous_people.htm. Retrieved 26 April 2008. 
  60. '^ "Albino Model Takes Industry by Storm: Struggling with Ridicule, Diandra Forrest Capitalizes on Unique Beauty (Women with Albinism Battle Ridicule, Part 2)". ABC News Video (New York City: American Broadcasting Company). 2 October 2009. http://abcnews.go.com/video/playerIndex?id=8739562. Retrieved 8 March 2011.  The segment was later aired on 20/20, as archived at http://abcnews.go.com/2020/video/albino-model-takes-industry-storm-11501968 (same footage, but dated 27 August 2010).
  61. ^ As "Ice", she is the female star of the DVDs Homegrown Video 663, Eye Contact 35 and Handjobs Across America 12; as "Icy", she appears more recently in Watermark at DesperateAmateurs.com.
  62. ^ "Images: NZ Leaves Solomon Islands", from New Zealand Defence Force press release, published in Scoop Independent News (online edition); June 26, 2002; Wellington, New Zealand; accessed January 8, 2007. Includes photo of Kaoni.
  63. ^ o' brienfamily.co.uk/Albinism/bianca.htm Albinism Through the Eyes of Bianca, by Bianca Knowlton, Bournemouth, England, 12 February 2007; specific page here
  64. ^ Rhymesayers Entertainment. "Rhymesayers Homepage - Brother Ali Biography". http://www.rhymesayers.com/aDetail.php?aId=8&cT=Bio. Retrieved 23 May 2007. 
  65. ^ Abraham, Tamara (14 December 2010). "Pale...and Very Interesting: Givenchy Casts Albino Model in Latest Ad Campaign". Daily Mail/Mail Online (London: Associated Newspapers Ltd). http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-1338506/Givenchy-casts-albino-model-Stephen-Thompson-latest-advertising-campaign.html. Retrieved 8 March 2011.  Also mentioned in ABC News publications: http://abcnews.go.com/search?searchtext=albino%20model
  66. ^ "David Wrench", BBC Wales — Music, bbc.co.uk; accessed 11 March 2007
  67. ^ "David Wrench Biography", BBC Wales — Music, bbc.co.uk, retrieved 11 March 2007
  68. ^ Oldies Music Guide Profile: Roy Orbison, by Robert Fontenot, About.com; accessed 27 January 2007.
  69. ^ MigalooWhale.org, Pacific Whale Foundation; Maui, Hawaii, USA, 2007; accessed 11 April 2007.
  70. ^ "Stormy seas for Migaloo and friends"; Darby, Andrew; Sydney Morning Herald, Sydney, Australia, 20 April 2005; accessed 11 April 2007
  71. ^ "Albino Penguin 'One-in-a-million'", no by-line, BBC News (online edition), 13 December 2002, accessed 11 April 2007.
  72. ^ "Zoo's Rare Albino Penguin Is Dead", no by-line, BBC News (online edition), 19 August 2004, accessed 11 April 2007.
  73. ^ FloquetDeNeu.es, Parc Zoològic de Barcelona, date of publication unknown (no earlier than 24 November 2003; accessed 11 April 2007.
  74. ^ "Pink dolphin appears in US lake"; Telegraph, United Kingdom, 5 March 2009; accessed 7 March 2009

External links